I Changed My Mind! (First Car)

So if you remember about 2 months ago I made a post about the car I decided to get as my first. Since then it's changed! I was wanting to get a 2014 BMW 1 Series , Sport 5-door Sports Hatch N47 2.0d (pictured below) and then I seen what is now going to be my first car!

Let me know what you think! Keep in mind I am 17!

OLD CHOICE

NEW CHOICE (2013 AUDI A4)

Let me know which one you like better and why!